Chuckie Egg
Classic v Modern
For me, Chuckie Egg on the BBC is the antithesis of "form over function". Yes, Henhouse Harry is cute and yes, the cyan antagonists are also charming - and charmingly animated. The whole "level" fits on the screen at once, and there's a definite sense of urgency as you play. The "form" part? Well, the graphics flicker as much as they possibly could, the duck being particularly prone to flickering and somewhat woodenly animated. Given the limitations of the hardware being used - well, let's just say that flickering graphics wasn't new to those of us playing the game in 1983, and it holds up bizarrely well even now. However the gameplay was and remains perfect. It's simply great fun, in a similar vein to Donkey Kong (one of my all-time arcade favourites). Gameplay over graphics.
Chuckie Egg 2017 is described on the Steam store with: "Run, jump, dodge, collect eggs! There's a new Harry in town as the popular platform game debuts on PC."
This hit me funny right off, as the original Chuckie Egg has been on the PC before - back in the 1980's, I believe, and I get the feeling that variations of it have cropped up now and then over time. But let's deal with this iteration.
The levels (barring small "bonus" levels) are pretty much the same as the BBC version - except they do not fit on a single screen, so screen scrolling is involved in order for you to see the entirety of the puzzle. The screenshots here are of the "same" first level as depicted in the screenshot from the BBC just up this page a bit. It's not much of a problem, especially for those of us who destroyed keyboard playing the original back in the day, but surprising - especially with all those extra pixels being available. It fractionally changes the nature of the game.
The game makes good use of the graphical improvements available on modern modern computers. The ostriches are a particular highlight IMO, but although the duck (Bertha?) has undergone a great redesign, the animation hasn't improved. A missed chance IMO.
As far as the sound goes, well - it's there. It strikes me very much as elevator music rather than something catchy that I'll wind up humming to myself at odd moments of any day at random. The music to "Blocked" (IIRC) on a GP32X handheld gaming device perhaps, or the music to "Zeliard" on the PC (I recall the music even when the game's name eludes me) occur to me as great examples of what this game could have benefitted from - something with an ear-worm aspect.
But what's this? For all these years I have been picturing Henhouse Harry as a dude - when all along Harry has apparently been a chick! I'm not at all sure that turning Harry into a baby bird rather than a rotund farmer makes any more sense, but then this is a video game so who am I to complain?
Overall I found this a lacklustre "update" of the original 8-bit versions, which by default is also easier to beat. You can increase difficulty from "Normal" in the Settings menu, but really "Normal" should be called "Easy".
If you fancy some more modern Chuckie-Egg fun I would suggest "Chuckie Egg 2017 Challenges". It's "more of the same" but at least the levels are new, to match the higher resolution graphics and improved sound. I'll mostly be playing the BBC version that holds the extra special sauce of nostalgia.